a)
To determine: The suitable outsourcing provider for logistics services using factor- rating method.
Introduction:
Factor-rating method:
The factor-rating method is a quantitative approach to make a decision from various alternatives such that the decision is beneficial to the firm involved. This method is utilized to decide on new layout, new locations, best supplier, outsourcing providers etc.
a)
Answer to Problem 10P
Garza should select worldwide delivery.
Explanation of Solution
Given information:
Ratings of Logistics Providers | ||||
Criterion | Weight | Overnight Shipping | Worldwide Delivery | United Freight |
Quality | 5 | 90 | 80 | 75 |
Delivery | 3 | 70 | 85 | 70 |
Cost | 2 | 70 | 80 | 95 |
Weights = 1-5 (5 – Highest)
Ratings = 1-100 (100 – Highest)
Formula to calculate weighted rating:
Formula to calculate weighted average:
Excel Formula:
Calculation for Overnight Shipping:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 450.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 210.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 140.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for Overnight shipping is 80.
Calculation for Worldwide delivery:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 400.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 255.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 160.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for worldwide delivery is 81.5.
Calculation for United Freight:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 375.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 210.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 190.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for United Freight is 77.5.
The weighted average value for Overnight Shipping is 80. The weighted average value for worldwide delivery is 81.5. The weighted average value for united Freight is 77.5. The weighted average value is more for worldwide delivery (81.5 > 80, 77.5)
Hence, Garza should select worldwide delivery.
b)
To determine: The suitable outsourcing provider for logistics services using factor- rating method when the weights are changed.
Introduction:
Factor-rating method:
The factor-rating method is a quantitative approach to make a decision from various alternatives such that the decision is beneficial to the firm involved. This method is utilized to decide on new layout, new locations, best supplier, outsourcing providers etc.
b)
Answer to Problem 10P
There is No Change.
Explanation of Solution
Given information:
Ratings of Logistics Providers | ||||
Criterion | Weight | Overnight Shipping | Worldwide Delivery | United Freight |
Quality | 10 | 90 | 80 | 75 |
Delivery | 6 | 70 | 85 | 70 |
Cost | 4 | 70 | 80 | 95 |
Weights = 1-10 (10 – Highest)
Ratings = 1-100 (100 – Highest)
Formula to calculate weighted rating:
Formula to calculate weighted average:
Excel Formula:
Calculation for Overnight Shipping:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 900.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 420.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 280.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for Overnight shipping is 80.
Calculation for Worldwide delivery:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 800.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 510.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 320.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for worldwide delivery is 81.5.
Calculation for United Freight:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 750.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 420.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 380.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for United Freight is 77.5.
The weighted average value for Overnight Shipping is 80. The weighted average value for worldwide delivery is 81.5. The weighted average value for united Freight is 77.5. The weighted average value is more for worldwide delivery (81.5 > 80, 77.5)
There is no change in the result because there is no change made to the ratings. The weights were doubled without changes to any other parameter. Hence, there is no change in the conclusion attained in part (a).
Hence, there is No change.
c)
To determine: The suitable outsourcing provider for logistics services using factor- rating method when there is 10% increase in Overnight Shipping ratings.
Introduction:
Factor-rating method:
The factor-rating method is a quantitative approach to make a decision from various alternatives such that the decision is beneficial to the firm involved. This method is utilized to decide on new layout, new locations, best supplier, outsourcing providers etc.
c)
Answer to Problem 10P
The best outsourcing provider is Overnight Shipping.
Explanation of Solution
Given information:
Ratings of Logistics Providers | ||||
Criterion | Weight | Overnight Shipping | Worldwide Delivery | United Freight |
Quality | 10 | 90 | 80 | 75 |
Delivery | 6 | 70 | 85 | 70 |
Cost | 4 | 70 | 80 | 95 |
Weights = 1-10 (10 – Highest)
Ratings = 1-100 (100 – Highest)
Formula to calculate weighted rating:
Formula to calculate weighted average:
Formula to calculate 10% of Overnight Shipping ratings:
Formula to calculate New Overnight Shipping rating:
Excel Formula:
Calculation of 10 % of Overnight Shipping ratings:
Quality:
The 10% value of Quality is 9.
Delivery:
The 10% value of delivery is 7.
Cost:
The 10% value of cost is 7.
Calculation of New Overnight Shipping ratings:
Quality:
The new quality overnight shipping rating is 99.
Delivery:
The new delivery overnight shipping rating is 77.
Cost:
The new cost overnight shipping rating is 77.
Calculation for Overnight Shipping:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 495.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 231.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 154.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for Overnight shipping is 88.
Calculation for Worldwide delivery:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 400.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 255.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 160.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for worldwide delivery is 81.5.
Calculation for United Freight:
Calculation of weighted rating:
The weighted rating is calculated by multiplying the individual rating with the weight assigned for each criterion.
Quality:
The weighted rating for Quality is 375.
Delivery:
The weighted rating for Delivery is 210.
Cost:
The weighted rating for Cost is 190.
Calculation of weighted average:
The weighted average is calculated by dividing the summation of the individual weighted rating by the summation of the individual weights.
The weighted average for United Freight is 77.5.
The weighted average value for Overnight Shipping is 88. The weighted average value for worldwide delivery is 81.5. The weighted average value for united Freight is 77.5. The weighted average value is more for Overnight Shipping (88 > 81.5, 77.5)
Hence, Garza should select Overnight Shipping.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 2 Solutions
Pearson eText Principles of Operations Management: Sustainability and Supply Chain Management -- Instant Access (Pearson+)
- Firm performance will increase if a good information system is installed for the reverse logisticssystem. Do you agree? Why?arrow_forwardYou are selected to be part of the team in the Raju’s Hill Strawberry Farm located in Cameron Highlands. (a) Examine the logistics activities throughout the supply chain from raw materials to end user. (b) Formulate the Integration Strategy to export Cameron Highland's strawberry products to Singapore. (c) Explain the benefits of implementing Vertical Integration.arrow_forwardPorter’s 5 forces model for the canada destination industry - Again, provide concrete examples to support your analysis End your discussion with a holistic approach, and provide your own comments on the success, potential, and sustainability of canada destination industry in which it operates.arrow_forward
- Your company has seen tremendous growth in sales within the U.S. and you now want to expand to the European market. Your logistics provider discussed the benefits of subcontracting your manufacturing to Asia. Question: What are some of the advantages and disadvantages of production outside the U.S.? Hint: The evolution Outsourcing, Nearsourcing and Friendshoringarrow_forwardTrue or false 3.2 suppliers of raw materials areparticipants in transportation.arrow_forwardWhich entry mode is most suitable for a firm that is trying to realise location and experience curve economies? Question 4Answer a. Licensing b. Wholly owned subsidiary c. Strategic Alliances d. Franchisingarrow_forward
- A. Discuss the similarities and differences between the logistics considerations for managers who direct global supply chains and those who direct purely domestic supply chains. Be specific, and explain how various supply chain elements are more important to one type of manager than the other.arrow_forwardSource Available at: https://propertywheel.co.za/2021/10/sa-remains-the-largest-most- sophisticated-warehousing-and-logistics-market-across-africa/ please read the above source and answer the following question a. Please critique supply chains and regional competitiveness in Africa and the regional location factor 3: Market dynamics of warehouses taking into consideration the extract above.arrow_forwardDefine Omni-channel logistics in your own words. Do you think the Omni-channel logistics model is replicable in the fashion clothing industry of Dhaka city? Why or why not? Discuss on the basis of key enablers of last mile delivery and dynamic fulfillment locations strategies.arrow_forward
- Fernando Garza’s firm wishes to use factor rating tohelp select an outsourcing provider of logistics services. a) With weights from 1–5 (5 highest) and ratings 1–100 (100 high-est), use the following table to help Garza make his decision: RATING OF LOGISTICS PROVIDERS CRITERION WEIGHT OVERNIGHTSHIPPINGWORLDWIDEDELIVERY UNITEDFREIGHTQuality 5 90 80 75Delivery 3 70 85 70Cost 2 70 80 95b) Garza decides to increase the weights for quality, delivery, andcost to 10, 6, and 4, respectively. How does this change yourconclusions? Why?c) If Overnight Shipping’s ratings for each of the factors increaseby 10%, what are the new results?arrow_forward1 Discuss how the use of Strategic Partnering helps to alleviate the bullwhip effect.2 What is the bullwhip effect and what impacts can it have in the supply chain?3 Discuss and elaborate on the following statement: “The selection of a superior location network can create substantial competitive advantage.â4 What are the penalties of facing highly variable demand? Are there any advantages?5 Show the elements involved in the process of deciding when to order and how much to order by using a âsawtooth modelâ of inventory.6 Distinguish between using an exact optimization technique and a heuristic to solve a problem?7 Explain why risk pooling across locations is attractive to extended supply chains.8 Discuss five (5) ways that the lead times within a supply chain can be reduced.9 âCycleWorld distributes the majority of their orders for pushbikes across 60 vendors so it was very important for them to manage this at a…arrow_forward1. Study the supply chain integration of companies operating in Namibia below and identify the TYPE OR LEVELof Integration involved in each case. Please justify your answer! c) A Producer Classification System has also been introduced; this tool enables Meatco to interact withits producers and provide first-rate service delivery to those producers who have the greatest impacton the business. d) Namibia Dairies (ND) established a depot at Katima Mulilo to have the ND portfolio available to allNamibians in all areas of the country. According to the ND Managing director, "the depot will alsoprovide a call and collect service to the Katima customer base to ensure stock availability; promotecross border trade, expand ND business, and ensure synergies with our sister company NamibiaBreweries Limited (NBL) at the Katima facility.arrow_forward
- Practical Management ScienceOperations ManagementISBN:9781337406659Author:WINSTON, Wayne L.Publisher:Cengage,Operations ManagementOperations ManagementISBN:9781259667473Author:William J StevensonPublisher:McGraw-Hill EducationOperations and Supply Chain Management (Mcgraw-hi...Operations ManagementISBN:9781259666100Author:F. Robert Jacobs, Richard B ChasePublisher:McGraw-Hill Education
- Purchasing and Supply Chain ManagementOperations ManagementISBN:9781285869681Author:Robert M. Monczka, Robert B. Handfield, Larry C. Giunipero, James L. PattersonPublisher:Cengage LearningProduction and Operations Analysis, Seventh Editi...Operations ManagementISBN:9781478623069Author:Steven Nahmias, Tava Lennon OlsenPublisher:Waveland Press, Inc.