There is an ongoing debate about the roles of quantitative and qualitative inputs in demand estimation and forecasting. Those in the qualitative camp argue that statistical analysis can only go so far. Demand estimates can be further improved by incorporating purely qualitative factors. Quantitative advocates insist that qualitative, intuitive, holistic approaches only serve to introduce errors, biases, and extraneous factors into the estimation task. Suppose the executive for the theater chain is convinced that any number of bits of qualitative information (the identity of the director, the film’s terrific script and rock-music sound track, the Hollywood “buzz” about the film during production, even the easing of his ulcer) influence the film’s ultimate box-office revenue. How might one test which approach—purely qualitative or statistical, provides better demand or revenue estimates? Are there ways to combine the two approaches? Provide concrete suggestions

There is an ongoing debate about the roles of quantitative and qualitative inputs in demand estimation and forecasting. Those in the qualitative camp argue that statistical analysis can only go so far. Demand estimates can be further improved by incorporating purely qualitative factors. Quantitative advocates insist that qualitative, intuitive, holistic approaches only serve to introduce errors, biases, and extraneous factors into the estimation task. Suppose the executive for the theater chain is convinced that any number of bits of qualitative information (the identity of the director, the film’s terrific script and rock-music sound track, the Hollywood “buzz” about the film during production, even the easing of his ulcer) influence the film’s ultimate box-office revenue. How might one test which approach—purely qualitative or statistical, provides better demand or revenue estimates? Are there ways to combine the two approaches? Provide concrete suggestions

Practical Management Science

6th Edition

ISBN:9781337406659

Author:WINSTON, Wayne L.

Publisher:WINSTON, Wayne L.

Chapter9: Decision Making Under Uncertainty

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 46P

See similar textbooks

Similar questions

The Baker Company wants to develop a budget to predict how overhead costs vary with activity levels. Management is trying to decide whether direct labor hours (DLH) or units produced is the better measure of activity for the firm. Monthly data for the preceding 24 months appear in the file P13_40.xlsx. Use regression analysis to determine which measure, DLH or Units (or both), should be used for the budget. How would the regression equation be used to obtain the budget for the firms overhead costs?
Play Things is developing a new Lady Gaga doll. The company has made the following assumptions: The doll will sell for a random number of years from 1 to 10. Each of these 10 possibilities is equally likely. At the beginning of year 1, the potential market for the doll is two million. The potential market grows by an average of 4% per year. The company is 95% sure that the growth in the potential market during any year will be between 2.5% and 5.5%. It uses a normal distribution to model this. The company believes its share of the potential market during year 1 will be at worst 30%, most likely 50%, and at best 60%. It uses a triangular distribution to model this. The variable cost of producing a doll during year 1 has a triangular distribution with parameters 15, 17, and 20. The current selling price is 45. Each year, the variable cost of producing the doll will increase by an amount that is triangularly distributed with parameters 2.5%, 3%, and 3.5%. You can assume that once this change is generated, it will be the same for each year. You can also assume that the company will change its selling price by the same percentage each year. The fixed cost of developing the doll (which is incurred right away, at time 0) has a triangular distribution with parameters 5 million, 7.5 million, and 12 million. Right now there is one competitor in the market. During each year that begins with four or fewer competitors, there is a 25% chance that a new competitor will enter the market. Year t sales (for t 1) are determined as follows. Suppose that at the end of year t 1, n competitors are present (including Play Things). Then during year t, a fraction 0.9 0.1n of the company's loyal customers (last year's purchasers) will buy a doll from Play Things this year, and a fraction 0.2 0.04n of customers currently in the market ho did not purchase a doll last year will purchase a doll from Play Things this year. Adding these two provides the mean sales for this year. Then the actual sales this year is normally distributed with this mean and standard deviation equal to 7.5% of the mean. a. Use @RISK to estimate the expected NPV of this project. b. Use the percentiles in @ RISKs output to find an interval such that you are 95% certain that the companys actual NPV will be within this interval.
Suppose that a regional express delivery service company wants to estimate the cost of shipping a package (Y) as a function of cargo type, where cargo type includes the following possibilities: fragile, semifragile, and durable. Costs for 15 randomly chosen packages of approximately the same weight and same distance shipped, but of different cargo types, are provided in the file P13_16.xlsx. a. Estimate a regression equation using the given sample data, and interpret the estimated regression coefficients. b. According to the estimated regression equation, which cargo type is the most costly to ship? Which cargo type is the least costly to ship? c. How well does the estimated equation fit the given sample data? How might the fit be improved? d. Given the estimated regression equation, predict the cost of shipping a package with semifragile cargo.
Stock market analysts are continually looking for reliable predictors of stock prices. Consider the problem of modeling the price per share of electric utility stocks (Y). Two variables thought to influence this stock price are return on average equity (X1) and annual dividend rate (X2). The stock price, returns on equity, and dividend rates on a randomly selected day for 16 electric utility stocks are provided in the file P13_15.xlsx. Estimate a multiple regression equation using the given data. Interpret each of the estimated regression coefficients. Also, interpret the standard error of estimate and the R-square value for these data.
The owner of a restaurant in Bloomington, Indiana, has recorded sales data for the past 19 years. He has also recorded data on potentially relevant variables. The data are listed in the file P13_17.xlsx. a. Estimate a simple regression equation involving annual sales (the dependent variable) and the size of the population residing within 10 miles of the restaurant (the explanatory variable). Interpret R-square for this regression. b. Add another explanatory variableannual advertising expendituresto the regression equation in part a. Estimate and interpret this expanded equation. How does the R-square value for this multiple regression equation compare to that of the simple regression equation estimated in part a? Explain any difference between the two R-square values. How can you use the adjusted R-squares for a comparison of the two equations? c. Add one more explanatory variable to the multiple regression equation estimated in part b. In particular, estimate and interpret the coefficients of a multiple regression equation that includes the previous years advertising expenditure. How does the inclusion of this third explanatory variable affect the R-square, compared to the corresponding values for the equation of part b? Explain any changes in this value. What does the adjusted R-square for the new equation tell you?
The file P13_22.xlsx contains total monthly U.S. retail sales data. While holding out the final six months of observations for validation purposes, use the method of moving averages with a carefully chosen span to forecast U.S. retail sales in the next year. Comment on the performance of your model. What makes this time series more challenging to forecast?
The file P13_42.xlsx contains monthly data on consumer revolving credit (in millions of dollars) through credit unions. a. Use these data to forecast consumer revolving credit through credit unions for the next 12 months. Do it in two ways. First, fit an exponential trend to the series. Second, use Holts method with optimized smoothing constants. b. Which of these two methods appears to provide the best forecasts? Answer by comparing their MAPE values.
The file P13_29.xlsx contains monthly time series data for total U.S. retail sales of building materials (which includes retail sales of building materials, hardware and garden supply stores, and mobile home dealers). a. Is seasonality present in these data? If so, characterize the seasonality pattern. b. Use Winters method to forecast this series with smoothing constants = = 0.1 and = 0.3. Does the forecast series seem to track the seasonal pattern well? What are your forecasts for the next 12 months?
Week Demand of beef 1 500 2 550 3 600 4 720 5 780 6 800 Corresponding weights are W1=0.6, W2=0.4 and W3=0.3 The 3-week weighted moving average to forecast- Week Demand of beef 3- weeks weighted moving average forecast 1 500 2 550 3 600 4 720 (500×0.6+550×0.4+600×0.3) / (0.6+0.4+0.3) = 538.46 5 780 (550×0.6+600×0.4+720×0.3) / (0.6+0.4+0.3) = 604.61 (600×0.6+720×0.4+780×0.3) / (0.6+0.4+0.3) = 678.46 Forecast for week 4,5 and 6 = 538.46, 604.61 and 678.46 4-week weighted moving average to forecast- Corresponding weights are W1=0.6, W2=0.4, W3=0.3, and W4=0.2 Week Demand of beef 4-weeks weighted moving average forecast 1 500 2 550 3 600 4 720 5 780 (500×0.6+550×0.4+600×0.3+720×0.2) / (0.6+0.4+0.3+0.2) = 562.66 (550×0.6+600×0.4+720×0.3+780×0.2) / (0.6+0.4+0.3+0.2) = 628 Forecast for week 6 and 7 = 562.66, 628…
Problem 3 Picante Corporation expects demand for mp3 players that they produce to increase. Demand for their mp3 players for last year was as follows: MONTH JANUARY FEBRUARY MARCH APRIL 2,150 2,000 2,200 AUGUST SEPTEMBER OCTOBER 2,450 2,700 2,850 DEMAND 2,100 MONTH JULY DEMAND 2,650 MAY JUNE 2,500 2,350 NOVEMBER DECEMBER 3,150 3,000 a. Using least squares regression analysis, what would you estimate demand to be for each month next year? b. To be reasonably confident of meeting demand, Picante Corporation decides to use three standard errors of estimate for safety. How many additional units should be held to meet this level of confidence?
Cost Estimation; High-Low and Regression Methods The Mac Davis Company specializesin the purchase, renovation, and resale of older homes. Mac employs several carpenters and paintersto do the work for him. It is essential for him to have accurate cost estimates so he can determinetotal renovation costs before he purchases a piece of property. If estimated renovation costs plus thepurchase price of a house are higher than the house’s estimated resale value, it is not a worthwhileinvestment.Mac has been using the home’s interior square feet for his exterior paint cost estimations. Recentlyhe decided to include the number of external openings—the total number of doors and windows ina house—as a cost driver. Their cost is significant because they require time-consuming preparatorywork and careful brushwork. The rest of the house usually is painted either by rollers or spray guns,which are relatively efficient ways to apply paint to a large area. Mac has kept careful records of theseexterior…
If a forecast can be made using a quantitative model, a forecaster need not use her personal opinion or subjective judgment anymore. True False