preview

Similarities Between Frankenstein And Edward Scissorhands

Good Essays

In both stunning stories of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Tim Burton’s Edward Scissorhands, the reader’s heart breaks, as s/he watches how an “other” becomes pitifully isolated by their loved ones or peers because of how they appear. Both protagonists, the creature and Edward Scissorhands, are created rather than naturally born into the world. With this and their abnormal distinctions came an enormous amount of dissension and discomfort from either their creators or their peers. The audience can’t help but sympathize with the “creatures”, because they recognize the “others” are far from malintentioned, but the materialism and fear within society prohibits this to be acknowledged. The two texts exemplify two characters in similar and contrasting …show more content…

Throughout Shelley’s story, the creature continuously resents Victor. Whether it’s through other novels like Paradise Lost, or having to find families to accept him, the monster cannot disregard the isolation and insecurity Victor instilled in him. To the contrary, In Tim Burton’s film, the creator is an insignificant factor. The story mainly focuses on Peg’s family who practically treated Edward as one of their own. Instead of resenting like the creature does, the audience can assume Edward feels very fortunate and very lucky to be a part of his new “family.” We are able to observe how the two stories contrast when the creature tells Victor, “‘Cursed Creator! Why did you form a monster so hideous that even you turned from me in disgust? God in pity made man beautiful and alluring, after his own image; but my form is a filthy type of yours, more horrid from its very resemblance. Satan had his companions, fellow-devils, to admire and encourage him; but I am solitary and detested,” (154). The hatred for Victor as the creature possesses is incomparable. This also proves the monster has to be extremely self-reliant, which is not a comfortable trait for a human to adapt. Humans are complacent knowing they have unconditional love and support. Family for instance, provides a person with more confidence because they know they have someone to fall back on. …show more content…

The two stories can both fall under the “gothic” theme. However, the way these gothic elements are depicted vary drastically. In Tim Burton’s film, we see brightly colored houses, bright summery dresses, bright colored cars. Everything appears very happy and carefree once Edward is brought into what seems like a new world to him. Even though we can account this as “gothic” due to Burton’s use of exploding stereotypes, the town is presented in a positive connotation. Frankenstein however, takes place in the eighteenth century among Geneva and the Swiss Alps. This arctic setting embodies an isolated, eerie, and cold environment, almost a parallel to how the monster feels after his countless rejections from other humans. The creature says, “The desert mountains and dreary glaciers are my refuge. I have wandered here many days; the caves of ice, which I only do not fear, are a dwelling to me [...] These bleak skies I hail, for they are kinder to me than your fellow-beings,” (114). Although the creature does not like being alone, it is the only way he knows. He is displeased by the chilly atmosphere and the spooky mountains, but he feels everything is out of his control. After wept-filled nights and monotonous searching, he is finally satisfied with residing in a small hovel. Edward on the other hand, leaves his, what seems like, haunted castle for a spunky town filled with

Get Access